James Talarico enters Election Day ahead of Ken Paxton in several late Texas Senate polls. The New York Times/Siena release puts him seven points ahead; other surveys show a smaller advantage, and one gives Paxton a narrow numerical lead. There is a credible opening for Talarico, with enough uncertainty to make premature celebration a mistake. Siena’s November 1 release and the polling comparison below establish that distinction.
The case for supporting him goes beyond the numbers. Texas has an opportunity to choose a senator campaigning on wider access to healthcare and lower household costs over a Trump-endorsed attorney general who tried to overturn the 2020 presidential result. Those are substantive reasons to prefer Talarico, whether his final polling advantage is seven points, three points or none. Sources: Talarico’s platform, the Texas Tribune’s candidate guide and its account of the election lawsuit.
One particularly revealing finding comes from comparing the Senate and governor’s races within the same surveys. It suggests that explaining this contest simply as Texas moving toward Democrats leaves something important out.
What the final Talarico vs. Paxton polls show
The following is a selected comparison of four recent polls whose original releases or tables were inspected. It is not a polling average.
| Pollster | Fieldwork or release date | Talarico | Paxton | Numerical advantage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| New York Times/Siena | Released November 1 | 50% | 43% | Talarico +7 |
| YouGov | October 26–29 | 51% | 47% | Talarico +4 |
| Research Co. | October 31–November 2 | 49% | 46% | Talarico +3 |
| Trafalgar Group | October 31–November 1 | 47.5% | 48.1% | Paxton +0.6 |
Sources: Siena, YouGov tables, Research Co. tables and methodology, Trafalgar report.
Research Co.’s figures here include undecided respondents. Its separate result among decided voters is 51%–48%; that does not mean 51% of its entire Texas sample supported Talarico. YouGov includes respondents leaning toward a candidate. Such differences matter when comparing apparent levels of support.
Trafalgar’s finding also belongs in the picture. Rounding its numbers to 48% apiece obscures Paxton’s small numerical advantage. Supporting Talarico is compatible with reporting evidence that complicates his prospects.
Nor does moving from one pollster’s three-point lead to another’s seven-point lead establish a late surge. Different methods can produce different estimates. AAPOR’s guide to interpreting polls also cautions that the uncertainty around a candidate’s share is different from the uncertainty around the lead.
The defensible conclusion is encouraging for Talarico: several late surveys put him ahead. None supplies a result before the votes are counted.
Abbott’s numbers expose the limits of a simple partisan explanation
YouGov surveyed 2,141 likely Texas voters. It found Talarico leading Paxton 51%–47%, while Republican Governor Greg Abbott led Democrat Gina Hinojosa 50%–49%.
That produces a five-percentage-point difference between the Democratic margins: plus four in the Senate contest, minus one for governor. Both estimates come from the same survey. Source: YouGov.
Research Co.’s full sample shows the same five-point gap: Talarico leads 49%–46%, while Hinojosa trails Abbott 44%–46%. Source: Research Co..
These comparisons suggest that the particular candidates matter alongside the wider political environment. They do not prove whether Talarico’s appeal, Paxton’s weaknesses, Abbott’s incumbency or other factors explain the difference. And a five-point gap between margins does not mean precisely 5% of voters are splitting their tickets; that requires examining paired individual responses.
An earlier University of Texas/Texas Politics Project poll provides additional context. Conducted September 25–October 5, it found 98% of Democratic likely voters backing Talarico, compared with 92% of Republican likely voters supporting Paxton. Paxton also received a favorable rating from 69% of Republican likely voters, against Abbott’s 89%. These are subgroup estimates from an earlier survey, not a measurement of Election Day behavior. Source: Texas Politics Project.
Taken together, the findings raise a serious question about Paxton’s ability to turn Republican identification into support for his own candidacy. A familiar party label does not erase a candidate’s record.
Paxton’s attempt to overturn the 2020 result belongs in this race
In December 2020, Paxton brought Texas’s challenge to presidential election results in Georgia, Michigan, Pennsylvania and Wisconsin. The lawsuit challenged election procedures and sought intervention in states whose results had delivered Joe Biden’s victory. The Supreme Court rejected Texas’s effort on December 11. Source: the Texas Tribune.
The legal distinction matters: the court’s order denied the filing for lack of standing. It was not a ruling after a full trial of the allegations.
The political judgment remains unavoidable. Paxton used the authority of his office to try to displace an election outcome that Trump had lost. That is a concrete basis for describing his conduct as anti-democratic.
A Senate seat would give him a role in federal legislation and the confirmation of presidential nominees. His willingness to challenge another party’s victory is therefore relevant to the power he is asking voters to give him.
Opposition to Paxton need not depend on an escalating sequence of insults. His documented conduct poses the harder question: why reward an official who responded to defeat by trying to overturn the result?
That standard must apply consistently. If Talarico loses a lawfully conducted election, disappointing polls would not be evidence that the outcome was stolen.
Talarico offers a governing case of his own
Talarico’s published economic platform proposes a federal public health-insurance option, caps on out-of-pocket costs for lifesaving medicines, stronger Medicare drug-price negotiations and action against healthcare monopolies. These are commitments his campaign has made, not benefits already delivered or independently established savings. Source: Talarico’s platform.
The Texas Tribune’s coverage of his economic agenda also describes proposals for universal childcare and reversing recent Republican tax cuts for the wealthy. Paxton’s competing plan emphasizes tax deductions for medical, housing and family expenses. Source: the Texas Tribune.
The choice deserves debate on those terms. Talarico puts public provision, access and corporate power near the centre of his approach. That is a compelling direction for people who believe government should take more responsibility for making essential services affordable.
His proposals still require scrutiny: how they would be financed, who would qualify, which measures could pass Congress and how implementation would work. Support should create an expectation of delivery, not exemption from examination.
But those questions are reasons to hold a prospective senator accountable. They do not cancel the substantive case for choosing him.
An opening is enough reason to take the choice seriously
The polling leaves room for either outcome. It also makes dismissing Talarico as a hopeless candidate difficult to justify.
His supporters do not need to claim that Texas has permanently changed, that every Republican voter has rejected Paxton, or that a favorable survey guarantees victory. The argument is strong enough without those embellishments.
Talarico offers an opportunity to pursue broader access to essential services and deny a promotion to an official whose record includes trying to overturn a presidential election. That is why he deserves support.
The polls measure the opportunity. The choice is whether to use it.